Momentum picked up in his 2nd yr at the poll, however the jury continues to be out on Scott Rolen’s Baseball Corridor of Popularity candidacy.

In 2019, his vote casting proportion jumped from 10.2% to 17.2% – an important build up that gives some promise with 8 extra years at the poll. 

Rolen used to be a top-tier 3rd baseman right through his 17-year primary league occupation that started in Philadelphia in 1996.

He used to be two-way participant – a defensive wizard with decent offensive credentials. On protection – each by means of conventional statistics and complicated size – he used to be one of the vital easiest 3rd basemen of his technology, successful 8 Gold Gloves. Offensively, his house run (316) and RBI (1,287) totals rank within the height 15 all time amongst 3rd basemen.

A 2nd spherical select by means of the Phillies in 1993, he made a direct affect when he reached the majors, unanimously successful the Nationwide League Rookie of the Yr award in 1997. The next season, he established himself as a valid celebrity with a .290/.391/.532 slash line, 31 house runs and 110 RBI, incomes his first Gold Glove.

The seven-time All-Superstar went directly to play for the St. Louis Cardinals, Toronto Blue Jays and Cincinnati Reds sooner than accidents took a toll and he retired in 2012. 

MLB TO DROP HAMMER?: Serious punishment looms for Houston Astros in sign-stealing scandal

ON THE MOVE: Rays achieve Jose Martinez from Cardinals for pitching prospect

FREE AGENTS: Who is left in the marketplace? Best 10 ultimate MLB FAs


  • Jeff Kent’s energy at 2nd base used to be unheard of
  • Underrated Bobby Abreu merits a more in-depth glance in first yr
  • Is defensive wizardry sufficient for Omar Vizquel?
  • Gary Sheffield’s Cooperstown pressure about to hit the next equipment

Case for

Rolen used to be a seven-time All-Superstar, a Silver Slugger and an eight-time Gold Glove winner at 3rd base. Amongst 3rd basemen, handiest Corridor of Famers Brooks Robinson (16) and Mike Schmidt (10) have extra Gold Gloves than Rolen. 

By means of complicated metrics, Rolen has the 9th easiest WAR (70.2, Wins Above Substitute) amongst 3rd basemen within the historical past of the sport. Seven of the 8 gamers with the next WAR are already enshrined in Cooperstown. Adrian Beltre, a sure-bet Corridor of Famer, isn’t eligible till 2024. 

And for comparability with Ron Santo, who used to be voted in by means of the Veterans Committee in 2012:


  • Santo: .277/.362/.464, 342 house runs, 1,331 RBI, 70.five WAR
  • Rolen: .281/.366/.490, 316 house runs, 1,287 RBI, 70.2 WAR


  • Santo: 5 Gold Gloves, 9 All-Superstar appearances 
  • Rolen: 8 Gold Gloves, seven All-Superstar appearances

Case towards

Rolen performed in technology when offensive numbers have been inflated. And whilst he does have excellent fee statistics, his general conventional numbers by no means measured as much as his opposite numbers like Chipper Jones and Vinny Castilla. Accidents hampered his occupation stats. He performed 150 video games 5 instances, however by no means after the 2003 season. 

Offensively, Rolen by no means led the majors in any primary statistical class. In 2004, he did end 2nd within the NL with 124 RBI, however that got here within the easiest offensive season of his occupation.  

Over portions of 17 seasons, Rolen gathered 2,077 hits. No place participant has been elected with fewer than that general since Johnny Bench in 1989 – and he is regarded as one of the vital largest catchers all time. 


When inspecting a participant’s Corridor of Popularity credentials, electorate generally tend to have a look at their top years. For Rolen, his eight-year span from 1997-2004 have been dominant. All through the ones years, he gathered a WAR of 46.3, which used to be 3rd easiest amongst hitters in the back of Barry Bonds (71.2) and Alex Rodriguez (62.4), however each who’ve been connected to performance-enhancing medicine. 

A lot of his WAR will also be attributed to his protection, however he additionally hit 222 house runs and drove in 813 RBI right through that span.

Rolen could also be one of the vital easiest 3rd basemen in Cardinals historical past and used to be inducted into their Corridor of Popularity this previous summer time. He used to be an integral a part of the membership that gained all of it in 2006, batting .421 with a 1.213 OPS within the International Sequence.


Poll monitoring by means of Ryan Thibodaux places Rolen at 50.7% in early poll finds, which places him excellent place for the long run. Whilst it’s not likely that he will get on this yr, the once-crowded poll is now getting thinner, making his probabilities higher with 8 extra years at the poll.  

Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.